The Neuroscience of Music Improvisation:
Mapping Creative Networks
How Spontaneous Musical Creation Reshapes Neural Pathways
Written by: Luke Chang | Edited by: Ellis Fertig | Graphic Design by: Annie Yuan
Picture a jazz musician lost in the moment, fingers dancing across piano keys, creating melodies that have never been heard before. What's happening in their brain during these magical moments of creativity?
Improvisation is the act of creating music on the fly, without any preparation at all. It may seem ridiculous to some, but it’s an essential part of both the creation and advancement of art. At the heart of musical improvisation, multiple different brain regions are involved in the process, each contributing to the spontaneous creation of melody, rhythm, and harmony. A study done by Charles Limb and Allen Braun using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) has shown that when musicians improvise, there's a notable increase in activity in the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC), an area associated with self-expression and emotions. Simultaneously, there's a decrease in activity in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC), which is typically involved in conscious decision-making and inhibition. This neural pattern suggests that during improvisation, our body specifically suppresses the part of the brain responsible for planned activity, and the brain enters a state of "flow," where self-consciousness diminishes and creativity flows more freely.
The benefits of improvisation have also been shown through an experiment that expanded on Limb’s work. Improvisation was shown to directly affect the nervous system of those performing, causing the brain to perform more effectively. Improvising eliminated the component of uncertainty most feel when performing normally. Additionally, a decrease in what’s known as “phase lag” was found, meaning communication between brain areas slowed down during improvisation. Although it may seem like a negative effect, it decreases the chances of musicians overthinking and creating that feeling of uncertainty, which an increase in phase lag could cause.
The implications of these findings reach far beyond music. Understanding how the brain coordinates this complex creative process could help us unlock mysteries about human creativity in general. It might even lead to new approaches in education and therapy, helping people tap into their creative potential more effectively. The very principle of improvisation allows for a more doubt-free environment as well as promoting spontaneity. It can serve as a way to treat mental health, social work, and even business fields.
Current research is continuing to explore how different types of improvisation affect the brain. For instance, researchers have found that creating rhythms engages brain circuits beyond the scope of just new melodies. When musicians improvise with harmony, they activate areas linked to emotional expression, perhaps explaining why certain chord progressions can move us so deeply and unconventional harmonies can seem so distressing.
This growing understanding of musical improvisation not only shows how creative humans can be but also provides a window into the potential of what we could achieve. As we continue to improvise on the spot, we move closer to understanding how the brain transforms abstract musical ideas into the spontaneous expression that has captivated audiences for centuries.
Extra:
An amazing short video that shows improv in action is by legendary blues musician B.B. King. He explains his thought process of improvising a slow, mellow melody and masterfully puts it into action. I would suggest anyone reading this to watch it as it not only exhibits improvisation at its best, but provides an excellent listening experience.
These articles are not intended to serve as medical advice. If you have specific medical concerns, please reach out to your provider.